| Player | Year | Hometown/School | Miscellaneous |
| Ben Foster | JR | Valparaiso, IN/Andrean | |
| Jake German | SR | Crawfordsville, IN/North Montgomery | |
| Seth Hensley | FR | Indianapolis, IN/Brebeuf | |
| Charlie Kelly | SR | Springfield, MO/Pembroke Hill | |
| Nathan Klopfenstein | FR | Cicero, IN/Noblesville | |
| Jordan Koch | SR | Bedford, IN/Bedford North Lawrence | |
| Scott Morrison | FR | Merrilville, IN/Andrean | |
| Luke Moton | SR | Batesville, IN/Batesville | |
| Andrew Palmer | SR | Suttons Bay, MI/Suttons Bay | |
| Michael Piggins | SO | Saugatuk, MI/Saugatuk | |
| Alex Robbins | SO | Bloomington, IN/Bedford North Lawrence | |
| Michael Wittman | SO | Evansville, IN/Bosse |